Economic growth may one day turn out be a curse rather than a good, and under no conditions can it either lead to freedom or constitute a proof for its existence.
Economists got away from really questioning how the world works, how decisions actually got made. If something doesn’t conform to neoclassical models…people are not somehow behaving themselves properly.
Brian Arthur (b.1945) U.S. economist. Interview, Strategy + Business (April-June 1998)
If economics wants to understand the new economy, it not only has to understand increasing returns and the dynamics of instability. It also has to look at cognition itself, something we have never done before in economics.
Brian Arthur (b.1945) U.S. economist. Interview, Strategy + Business (April-June 1998)
The invisible hand is not perfect. Indeed, the invisible hand is a little bit arthritic…I’m a believer in free markets, but I think we need to be less naïve. We need to accept that markets give us pretty good solutions, but occasionally they will lock in something inferior.
Brian Arthur (b.1945) U.S. economist. Interview, Strategy + Business (April-June 1998)
We’re facing a danger that economics is rigorous deduction based upon faulty assumptions. Science after science gets that way from time to time. When it does, we’re in real trouble.
Brian Arthur (b.1945) U.S. economist. Interview, Strategy + Business (April-June 1998)
The modern history of economics theory is a tale of evasions of reality.
Humanity seems bent on creating a world economy primarily based on goods that take no material form. In doing so, we may be eliminating any predictable connection between creators and a fair reward for the utility others may find in their works.
There is no inherent mechanism in our present system which can with certainty prevent competitive sectional bargaining for wages from setting up a vicious spiral of rising prices under full employment.
Economist, n. A special (but not particular) kind of liar.
This is the generation that claims education, skills, and technology as the instruments of economic prosperity and personal fulfillment, not old battles between state and market.
A national economy, like an individual business…is the sum of the spiritual and mental qualities of its people, and its output of value will be only as strong as the values of society.
Economics is a metaphysical rather than mathematical science in which intangible spiritual values and attitudes are at least as important as physical assets and morals more fundamental than the money supply.
As the economy gets better, everything else gets worse.
Voodoo economics.
It’s important for folks to understand that when there’s more trade, there’s more commerce.
Respectable Professors of the Dismal Science.
Here lies one who knew how to get around him men who were cleverer than himself.
Unlimited economic growth has the marvelous quality of stilling discontent while maintaining privilege. A fact that has not gone unnoticed among liberal economists.
It’s the economy, stupid.
The difference between buyers and sellers blurs to the point where both are in a web of economic, informational and emotional exchange.
Corporate intentions and capabilities to create cross-national strategic alliances are affected by the ongoing structural changes of the global and regional economy.
I have no interest in celebrities. If all the superrich disappeared, the world economy would not even notice. The superrich are irrelevant to the economy.
Everybody is always in favour of general economy and particular expenditure.
Economics is not a science in the sense that a policy can repeatedly be applied under similar conditions and will repeatedly produce similar results.
Positive economics is in principle independent of any particular ethical position or normative judgment…In short, positive economics is or can be an “objective” science.
The people are opposed to it. And who is being stupid in all of this, in my opinion, is the business community in Europe. They’re not going to benefit from the euro, they’re going to be harmed by it.
If freedom were not so economically efficient it certainly wouldn’t stand a chance.
Economists may not know how to run the economy, but they know how to create shortages or gluts simply by regulating prices below the market, or artificially supporting them from above.
Neoclassical economics…has uncovered important truths about the nature of money and markets because its fundamental model of rational self-interested human behavior is correct about 80 percent of the time.
Virtually all economic activity in the contemporary world is carried out not by individuals but by organizations that require a high degree of social cooperation.
The attraction of power we take for granted in politics.. But in economics…the thrust…is for pecuniary return, for money. And I have always felt that denies in the economic world a very large part of the motivation.
K. Galbraith (b.1908) U.S. economist and diplomat. Interview, Conversations with History series, Institute of International Studies, University of California, Berkeley. “Intellectual Journey: Challenging the Conventional Wisdom” (march 27, 1986)
In economics, hope and faith coexist with great scientific pretension and also a deep desire for respectability.
K. Galbraith (b.1908) U.S. economist and diplomat. New York Times Magazine (June 1970)
The Affluent Society
K. Galbraith (b.1908) U.S. economist and diplomat. Book title. The Affluent Society (1958)
Monetary policy suffers from the unfortunate absence of any occult effect. It has long been clear that economic management…would be greatly facilitated if resort could occasionally be had to witchcraft.
K. Galbraith (b.1908) U.S. economist and diplomat. The Affluent Society (1958), ch. 16
Trickle-down theory-the less than elegant metaphor that if one feeds the horse enough oats, some will pass through to the road for the sparrows.
K. Galbraith (b.1908) U.S. economist and diplomat. The Culture of Contentment (1992)
There are three kinds of economist. Those who can count and those who can’t.
Capital is a result of labor, and is used by labor to assist it in further production. Labor is therefore the employer of capital.
The new mixed economy looks…for a synergy between public and private sectors.
Unfortunately monetarism, like Marxism, suffered the only fate that for a theory is worse than death: it was put into practice.
The volatility at the core of deregulated financial institutions makes a world economy that is organized as a system of free markets essentially unstable.
Institutions of the newer participants in global finance had not been tested, until recently…recent crisis have underscored certain financial structure vulnerabilities that are not readily assuaged in the short run.
We may be in a rapidly evolving international financial system with all the bells and whistles of the so-called new economy. But the old-economy rules of prudence are as formidable as ever. We violate them at our own peril.
The recent period has been marked by a transformation to an economy that is more productive as competitive forces become increasingly intense and new technologies raise the efficiency of our businesses…While these tendencies were no doubt in train in the “old,” pre-1990s economy, they accelerated over the past decade as a number of technologies with their roots in the cumulative innovations of the past half-century began to yield dramatic economic returns.
History cannot be reduced to a set of statistics and probabilities.
An economy that adds value through information, ideas, and intelligence-the Three I Economy-offers a way out of the apparent clash between material growth and environmental resources.
The market is a mechanism for sorting the efficient from the inefficient, it is not a substitute for responsibility.
Economists can be called the worldly philosophers for they sought to embrace in a scheme of philosophy the most worldly of man’s activities-his drive for wealth.
The eighties was an era when many companies were asset rich and cash poor.
Manufacturers…gradually shift their places, leaving those countries and provinces which they have already enriched, and flying to others, whether they are allured by the cheapness of provisions and labour.
Investment is not only volatile, it is the key motor of the economy’s prosperity because it has a snowball effect.
No less than war or statecraft, the history of Economics has its heroic ages.
When future historians look back on our way of curing inflation…they’ll probably compare it to bloodletting in the Middle Ages.
Observation of realities has never, to put it mildly, been one of the strengths of economic development.
Did you ever think that making a speech on economics is a lot like pissing down our leg? It seems hot to you but it never does to anyone else.
We must have an economy that does not force the migrant worker’s child to miss school in order to earn…just so the family can eat. That is the moral bankruptcy that trickle-down economics is all about.
To take full advantage of the potential in e-business, leaders must lead differently, and people must work together differently. Let’s call this new way of working e-culture-the human side of the global information era, the heart and soul of the new economy.
Good economics is good politics.
It is Enterprise which build and improves the world’s possessions…If Enterprise is afoot, Wealth accumulates whatever may be happening to Thrift; and if Enterprise is asleep, Wealth decays, whatever Thrift may be doing.
The Economic Problem…the problem of want and poverty and the economic struggle between classes and nations, is nothing but a frightful muddle, a transitory and unnecessary muddle.
The ideas of economists and political philosophers…are more powerful than is commonly understood. Indeed the world is ruled by little else. Practical men who believe themselves to be quite exempt from any intellectual influences, are usually the slaves of some defunct economist.
There are no intrinsic reasons for the scarcity of capital.
The engine which drives enterprise is not thrift but profit.
When the facts change, I change my mind.
Economics is a subject that does not greatly respect one’s wishes.
I have been….moved to wonder whether my job is a job or a racket, whether economists, and particularly economic theorists, may not be in the position that Cicero, citing Cato, ascribed to the augurs of Rome-that they should cover their faces or burst into laugher when they met on the street.
Costs merely register competing attractions.
Like nature, our economic system remains, in the long run, stable and rational…We welcome the inevitable seasons of our economy! How foolish of us.
The notion that economic life is a distinct realm, governed by immutable laws of narrow self-interest, is giving way to a much older notion: economic life is only one strand in the rich web of human relationships.
Today it’s fashionable to talk about the New Economy, or the Information Economy, or the Knowledge Economy. But when I think about the imperatives of this market, I view today’s economy as the Value Economy. Adding value has become more than just a sound business principle; it is both the common denominator and the competitive edge.
Monopoly is business at the end of its journey.
It seems that nearly every American either has a share of federal spending or has a close relative who does.
Behind the screen of the ballot, the real holders of power…are the great industrial and monetary monopolies who own our national economic life.
If a business can achieve high returns then it will accumulate more equity and it will have more leeway to reinvest on its own.
Political work is the life-blood for all economic work.
Political Economy or Economics is a study of mankind in the ordinary business of life.
A commodity appears, at first sight, a very trivial thing, and easily understood. Its analysis shows that is, in reality, a very queer thing, abounding in metaphysical subtleties and theological niceties.
A nation is not in danger of financial disaster merely because it owes itself money.
One speaks with great respect of economists, if only because they represent such a variety of opinions.
I accept the proposition that there has been a significant improvement in underlying productivity growth in the United States, that it is very closely tied to improvements in information and communications technology, and that it is likely to spread around the world. But I resist the new economy label because it seems to encourage a disrespect for the old rules that could seriously undermine our success in taking advantage of the new opportunities.
So, is there a “new economy?” The answer is: It depends. It depends on how you define new economy, and it depends on where you live.
There are broader and narrower definitions of the new economy. The narrow version defines the new economy in terms of two principal developments: first, an increase in the economy’s maximum sustainable growth rate and, second, the spread and increasing importance of information and communications technology.
The Broader interpretation that often seems to underlie the new economy label is that we are witnessing a more fundamental change in the paradigm. The old rules no longer apply. Throw out the NAIRU. Heck, throw out supply and demand. No limits, no business cycles.
Political Economy as a branch of science is extremely modern; but the subject with which its enquiries are conversant has in all ages necessarily constituted one of the chief practical interests of mankind.
Everybody thinks of economics whether he is aware of it or not. In joining a political party or in casting his ballot, the citizen implicitly takes a stand upon essential economic theories.
The market economy as such does not respect political frontiers. Its field is the world.
Humans have trouble with economics, as you may have noticed, and not just because economic circumstances sometimes cause them to starve. Humans seem to have an innate inability to pay attention to economic principles.
J. O’Rourke (b.1947) U.S. humorist and journalist. Eat the Rich (1998), ch. 1
Economics is not an attempt to generalize human desires or human behavior; but to generalize the phenomena of price.
What we are left with is an overmanipulated economy that can’t function normally.
Efforts to preserve all industries will lower the national standard of living.
One of the soundest rules to remember when making forecasts in the field of economics is that whatever is to happen is happening already.
A friend of mine was asked to a costume ball a short time ago. He slapped some egg on his face and went as a liberal economist.
In a world where routine production is footloose…competitive advantage lies not in one-time breakthroughs but in continual improvements. Stable technologies get away.
Economics limps along with one foot in untested hypothesis and the other in untestable slogans.
The first essential for economists…is to…combat, not foster, the ideology which pretends that values which can be measured in terms of money are the only ones which count.
Unequal distribution of income is an excessively uneconomic method of getting the necessary saving done.
The purpose of studying economics is not to acquire a set of ready-made answers to economic questions, but to learn to avoid being deceived by economists.
This movement was the origin of the whole system of modern economic administration. It has revitalized the way of doing business all over the world.
We have always known that heedless self-interest was bad morals; we know now that it is bad economics.
A nobler economics…is not afraid to discuss spirit and conscience, moral purpose and the meaning of life, an economics that aims to educate and elevate people, not merely to measure their low-grade behavior.
Economics is as much a study in fantasy and aspiration as in hard numbers-maybe more so.
As in the instances of alchemy, astrology, witchcraft, and other such popular creeds, political economy, has a plausible idea at the root of it.
The industrial era assumed the economy of scarcity, but now we have both the economy of scarcity and the economy of abundance: ideas are unlimited.
The work of Smith is only a confused assemblage of the soundest principles of Political Economy, supported by luminous examples and by the most curious notions of statistics, mingled with instructive reflections.
Modern economic thinking…is peculiarly unable to consider the long term and to appreciate man’s dependence on the natural world.
F. Schumacher (1911-77) British economist and conservationist. Speech, Blackpool, England. “Clean Air and Future Energy” (October 19, 1967)
Small is Beautiful
F. Schumacher (1911-77) British economist and conservationist. Book title. Referring to the importance of small-scale economics. Small is Beautiful (1973)
The metal of economic theory is in Marx’s pages immersed in such a wealth of steaming phrases as to acquire a temperature not naturally its own.
The market economy succeeds not because some people’s interests are suppressed and other people are kept out of the market, but because people gain individual advantage from it.
The generally accepted theory is that financial markets tend towards equilibrium, and…discount the future correctly. I operate using a different theory, according to which financial markets cannot possibly discount the future correctly because the do not merely discount the future; they help to shape it.
Studying economics is not a good preparation for dealing with it.
Economic systems are not value-free columns of numbers based on rules of reason, but ways of expressing what varying societies believe is important.
One of the peculiarities of economics is that it still rests on a behavioral assumption-rational utility maximization-that has long since been rejected by sociologists and psychologists.
Economists are always recommending the elimination of this or that “market imperfection”…no astrophysicist recommends the elimination of planets that he does not like.
Economics and ethics are not mutually exclusive.
Economics is a “dismal science,” we don’t believe things are perfect, we don’t believe there are free lunches. We believe there are trade-offs and costs and sacrifices.
Instead of investing in the goods as they pass between producer and consumer, as the merchant does, the businessman now invests in the processes of industry.
The corset is, in economic theory, substantially a mutilation, undergone for the purpose of lowering the subject’s vitality and rendering her permanently and obviously unfit for work.
There are only four ways to create value in the New Economy, and they’re really simple: information, entertainment, convenience, and savings.
My views about economics are very simple. I think we know very little. We know some things, but our knowledge is limited…It is very important having humility in managing economics.
It is not that pearls fetch a high price because men have dived for them; but on the contrary, men have dived for them because they fetch a high price.
As long as capital-both human and money-can move toward opportunity, trade will not balance.
The first law of economics is that when the price goes up, consumption comes down. This is a divine law.
